Two Ads I Like and One I Don’t – Duncan Shields

In this long-standing feature, Branding in Asia reaches out to experts in the ad world to get their input on ads they like and those that they are not so crazy about.

This week Duncan Shields, Creative Director at Sydney-based Redengine SCC chimes in with his two picks and a pan.


One I Like

“We All Win” – Microsoft

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_YISTzpLXCY


 

Why I like it: It captures so much life.

Using ‘real’ people in ads is not easy, getting an emotional story arc from a whole group of them is even harder. And don’t let the ‘underproduced’ style fool you – lo-fi shooting doesn’t automatically add authenticity, like Google Pixel 3 – Group Selfie Cam for example.  Authenticity comes from great direction and editing – hats off.

A Pleasure to Follow – Audi

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyJxlJXBT-U

Why I like it: I absolutely love ads that offer as much entertainment factor as the content they interrupt and this is a great example of doing just that. This ad oozes craft at every turn (excuse the pun).


 

From the overall look to the great choice in music, all the way down to the performances of each of the characters (the perp on the backseat is my favorite). Even the most weathered and cynical creatives would find it hard not to smile at the silliness of the situation when the reveal comes around at the end. It’s a good, old-fashioned entertaining ad that displays huge amounts of skill and craftsmanship. More of these, please.

One I like less than the others (quite a lot less)

Change Up the Usual – Stella Artois

Perhaps an obvious choice but one that bothered me so much, I haven’t been able to shake it from my memory. You guessed it, it’s the Stella Artois Superbowl ad with Carrie Bradshaw and the Dude:

I think the thing that bothers me most about that ad is that it’s a Stella Artois ad. It now sits alongside some of the best beer ads ever made and quite frankly, it doesn’t stack up at all.

Stella ads used to be right at the pinnacle of creative storytelling – hell, I got into advertising dreaming of making ads like Stella used to.

Ads like this:

And this:

And I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the production of both of these ads combined cost less than Carrie’s Cosmopolitan… sorry, Stella Artois.

Duncan Shields

Duncan Shields

Duncan is the Creative Director at Redengine SCC in Australia.

Read More

subscribe & get more brand in your diet

newsletter

get more brand in your diet

We never share your info,
we only share ours