Brand Amnesia

Why does an industry obsessed with being remembered keep forgetting what it creates?

Image AI-Generated by BIA

There is a peculiar moment in advertising when a brand’s most recognisable work suddenly becomes its biggest problem. Usually, somebody walks into a meeting and says, “We’ve been doing this for a while.” Nobody mentions that this might be precisely why people recognise it. Instead, the room gets excited. New direction. New visual language. New personality. Possibly a new font, because nothing says transformation quite like changing the typography.

Six months later, we have a beautiful campaign. The brand, meanwhile, is introducing itself again.

I’ve started calling this brand amnesia. We spend years trying to make brands memorable, then behave as though familiarity is something to be embarrassed about. And as an art director, I suspect we’re partly responsible.

advertisement

The beautiful problem with creative people

Art people have a particular weakness. We fall in love with possibilities. Give us a frame and we’ll find twenty ways to improve it. Change the angle. Move the light. Rethink the composition.

And sometimes, after three hours of experimenting, we’ll discover the original frame was better.

We won’t necessarily announce this immediately.

advertisement

But art direction has a responsibility beyond making things look extraordinary. A brand develops its own visual accent over time. Certain colours, compositions, characters and storytelling behaviours begin to feel familiar. People may not consciously know why something belongs to a particular brand. They simply recognise it. That recognition has value. And sometimes, our obsession with creating something new makes us forget how difficult it was to build.

Three films. One personality

I remember working on Babyshop’s Lots More for Less campaign at Leo Burnett Dubai alongside Divyan Kriplani, a good friend and creative sparring partner, and Farhan Siddiqui, my colleague and copy-side creative partner. The challenge was interesting. How do you make affordability desirable without making the brand look like it’s permanently announcing a clearance sale?

We created three films: ‘Rolling in Style’, ‘Nap Like a King’ and ‘Born to Slay’.

Children behaved with the confidence of people who had apparently achieved everything in life before learning to tie their shoelaces.

A little celebrity attitude. A touch of royalty. Fashion, confidence and wonderfully unnecessary levels of self-importance. Directed by Trevor McMahan, the films had different situations and different jokes, but shared a particular attitude towards childhood.

Three stories. One personality.

And that’s the beautiful frustration of working with good copy people. Divyan and Farhan could challenge the thinking behind a visual just when I was becoming rather attached to it. In return, the art could push the writing somewhere unexpected.

I sometimes think our creative conversations belonged inside the Millennium Falcon. Three people with strong opinions about the journey, occasional disagreements about the controls, and one art director wondering whether the cockpit could use better lighting.

Somehow, the ship moved forward.

The lesson wasn’t that three films automatically build long-term brand recognition. That takes time and evidence. It was that one clear creative character could produce different stories without becoming a different character every time.

We saved the artwork. We forgot the thinking

Here’s something I’ve noticed over the years. Agencies are excellent at archiving finished work. We have the films, the key visuals, the presentations, the photography, the guidelines and enough final artwork folders to keep an archaeologist employed for decades.

But how much of the thinking survives? Why did we choose that character? What made the humour right for the brand? Which beautiful visual direction did we reject because it had nothing to do with the idea?

Those conversations often contain the most valuable knowledge. Yet when accounts move, teams change or new leadership arrives, that knowledge can disappear. The next team inherits the files, but not necessarily the judgment that produced them. It’s like inheriting a beautifully designed house without knowing which walls are holding it up.

Naturally, the first suggestion is renovation.

This is where advertising needs a better sense of creative inheritance. A creative history should explain the decisions, not merely display the results.

Originality doesn’t always require demolition

Creative people like leaving their mark. A new creative director arrives. A new agency wins the account. A new marketing team takes ownership. Everybody wants to bring something fresh. Fair enough. That’s part of the job. But sometimes, in our enthusiasm to demonstrate what we can do, we overlook what the brand has already earned. A familiar character becomes outdated. A recognisable photographic style feels restrictive. A strong platform gets replaced because someone wants a completely different territory.

Maybe those changes are necessary. Maybe they aren’t. The responsibility of a good creative leader is knowing the difference.

Sometimes, in our enthusiasm to demonstrate what we can do, we overlook what the brand has already earned.

I admire art directors who can create an extraordinary visual world. I have even more respect for those who can recognise when the smartest decision is to build upon someone else’s good idea. That requires a different kind of confidence.

Nobody hands you a trophy for protecting the right shade of yellow.

But sometimes the greatest contribution isn’t changing the visual language. It’s finding a new way to speak it.

A brand isn’t a portfolio piece

Perhaps this is the distinction we sometimes forget. An art director’s portfolio benefits from variety. Different categories, different aesthetics, different challenges. A brand benefits from being recognisable. Those aren’t identical ambitions.

What’s exciting for the person making the advertisement isn’t automatically valuable to the person seeing it.

Consumers don’t follow our internal creative journeys. They don’t know a new agency has taken over or that the marketing department has appointed a new creative lead. They simply encounter a brand. And every time they do, they’re learning what that brand looks, sounds and feels like.

Consumers don’t follow our internal creative journeys. They don’t know a new agency has taken over or that the marketing department has appointed a new creative lead. They simply encounter a brand.

Of course, consistency shouldn’t become a prison. Familiarity without imagination eventually becomes wallpaper. The challenge is making the familiar surprising again. Think of a brilliant actor returning to a character across multiple films. The situations change, the stakes change, the story moves forward. But the character remains someone we recognise. Brands can work the same way. Evolution becomes interesting when there’s something worth evolving.

What should we keep?

I’d love to see creative departments begin new assignments with a slightly different conversation. Before discussing what needs to change, spend some time understanding what has already been built. Study the previous work. Understand the decisions behind it. Find out what people genuinely remember, rather than what the creative team hopes they remember.

Then challenge it.

Some elements will deserve to survive. Others will have lost their relevance. A few might reveal possibilities nobody noticed the first time. That’s where creative leadership becomes genuinely interesting. Because the next great idea doesn’t always need a blank canvas. Sometimes it needs someone who understands what’s already on it.

We spend our careers trying to create work people remember. Perhaps we should get a little better at remembering it ourselves.

And maybe, before announcing the next big creative refresh, we should ask one rather unfashionable question:

“What would be stupid to throw away?”

 

About the author: Syed Shuja Hussain is an Independent Creative Director & Brand Strategist.

Subscribe to the Almost Daily Update

We never share your info, we only share ours

Read More

the latest

Explore

advertisement

advertisement

Featured spotlight

Subscribe to our Newsletter

We never share your info. We only share ours.